But Allen, a notorious pessimist disguised as a romantic, does not let Gil rest here. Gil falls for Adriana (Marion Cotillard), a beautiful muse living in the 1920s who has loved Picasso and Modigliani. At first, Gil thinks he has found heaven. But then, he and Adriana take a carriage ride through another midnight—and they land in the 1890s (the Belle Époque).
Wilson’s "Wow" replaces Allen’s "I'm dying." He approaches Hemingway with genuine, childlike awe, not anxiety. This makes the audience root for him. When he defends sentimentalism against Paul the pseudo-intellectual, we cheer. Wilson plays Gil as a man who isn't broken, just displaced. It is arguably the role of his career. Midnight in Paris is frequently misunderstood as a love letter to the past. It is, in fact, a brilliantly constructed warning against Nostalgia Syndrome —the belief that you would have been happier in another time. midnight in. paris
Here, Adriana is ecstatic. She declares the 1890s the real Golden Age. To her horror, the artists of the 1890s (Toulouse-Lautrec, Gauguin) lament that they should have lived during the Renaissance. But Allen, a notorious pessimist disguised as a