If you are a purist who believes in a director’s intended framing, stick with the 2.39:1 Blu-ray. Roland Emmerich framed the movie to hide the seams of the effects and to keep the action horizontal.
For the 1998 Godzilla , the "Full Screen" DVD was a pan-and-scan job (where the editor chooses which 1.33 portion of the 2.39 image to show). Instead, Sony Pictures chose to produce an Open Matte transfer. They went back to the original camera negative and scanned the full 1.33:1 frame as it was shot, then simply centered it for 4:3 televisions. Godzilla 1998 Open Matte
Many viewers argue that the Open Matte version feels more immersive on modern 16:9 monitors. If you zoom a 2.39 image to fill a 16:9 screen, you lose the sides. But the Open Matte fits a 16:9 screen natively without cropping the horizontal information. It turns the movie into a pseudo-IMAX experience. If you are a purist who believes in
When Godzilla was released on DVD, studios faced a dilemma. Many consumers still had 4:3 CRT televisions (the square boxes). While "widescreen" DVDs existed, many retailers stocked "Full Screen" versions because average viewers hated "black bars." Instead, Sony Pictures chose to produce an Open